Palm Sunday Under Sleeping Shepherds

When the sanctuary is ringed by cowards, flatterers, and hirelings, Christ still walks toward His Passion and gathers the faithful around His Cross

“Every knee should bend”

Palm Sunday begins with a humiliation the world cannot understand. The Church places before us the great descent of Philippians 2, the eternal Son emptying Himself, taking the form of a servant, accepting obedience unto death, even the death of the Cross. That is the road to exaltation. That is the pattern. First abasement, then vindication. First dereliction, then glory.

For traditional Catholics living through this long post-conciliar wreckage, that sequence is important. We are tempted to judge everything by visible power. Who holds the offices. Who gets the microphones. Who receives praise from bishops. Who is invited into respectable Catholic circles. Who is told to wait patiently while every outrage is normalized and every betrayal is rebranded as pastoral sensitivity. Palm Sunday tears that false standard to pieces. Christ is never less King than when the world thinks it has finally reduced Him to weakness.

Instead of hiding the ugliness, the liturgy gives it to us raw. False witnesses. Cowardly disciples. Purchased consciences. A governor who knows the truth and still sacrifices it to public pressure. Clerics who hate holiness more than they fear God. A mob that prefers Barabbas. And over all of it, the silence of Christ. Not the silence of surrender, but of majesty.

That silence is part of our instruction now. We do not live in an age where ecclesiastical prominence is a reliable sign of fidelity. Quite the opposite. The men who speak most easily of dialogue, accompaniment, inclusion, and unity often grow strangely severe whenever Catholics ask for clarity, reverence, or the old religion whole and entire. They can find patience for the destroyers. They have none for the faithful.

The knife edge of this year’s Palm Sunday

This year the epistle lands with unusual force. “At the Name of Jesus every knee should bend.” The Church kneels there because the whole cosmos belongs to Christ. Angels kneel. Men kneel. Devils kneel. All things are under His dominion. The gesture has meaning because the object has meaning. Knees are not morally neutral when they meet the ground in a religious act.

That is why the reports surrounding Leo XIV’s 1995 Brazil episode have struck so many Catholics like a blow to the chest. The then Fr. Prevost knelt and prostrated himself during a “Celebration of the Rite of Pachamama (Mother Earth).”

That is crucial on a day when the Church commands us to kneel at the Name above every name. The contrast is revolting. Christ humbled Himself to death on the Cross. The modern churchman humiliates himself before the world. Christ receives the genuflection of heaven and earth because He is Lord. The new ecumenical and anthropological religion scatters gestures of reverence in every direction, toward cultures, symbols, sensibilities, myths, and “the earth,” as though man becomes noble by blurring the line between creature and Creator.

No wonder so many Catholics feel sickened. No wonder many also feel abandoned by the Catholic media class that spent years lecturing the laity about the danger of silence, only to discover fresh reserves of tact once Leo arrived. Yet even here Palm Sunday steadies the soul. The scandal is real. The nausea is real. But scandal does not alter the throne of Christ. Bad men can desecrate signs, offices, language, even sanctuaries. They cannot depose the Son of God.

Gethsemani is the place of the remnant

The Passion according to St. Matthew begins in the garden, where Christ asks for companions and finds sleep.

There is the whole tragedy of the Church in miniature. The Lord enters His agony. The chosen men cannot stay awake one hour. He warns, exhorts, returns, finds them sleeping again. He is not surprised. He has already measured their weakness. Still, He commands them to watch.

That command is for us. Watch. Pray. Stay near. Do not drift into the narcotic haze that has swallowed so much of the Catholic world. There is a spiritual sleep peculiar to times of ecclesiastical corruption. It speaks in pious clichés. It tells the faithful that public lies are not worth naming, that wolves should be treated as weather, that one can always postpone judgment until some future decade when the evidence is impossible to deny. It confuses docility with sedation.

Palm Sunday cuts through this deception. The disciples did not help Christ by sleeping reverently. They failed Him. The men of this hour do not help the Church by yawning through apostasy with folded hands and respectable manners. Watchfulness is not hysteria. It is fidelity under pressure. It is the refusal to let your moral senses be drugged by constant exposure to outrage.

Some of the strongest souls in the Church right now are not the men with platforms. They are the Catholics who still keep the fast, still make the long drive to a reverent Mass, still teach their children the old prayers, still feel grief when holy things are profaned, still have the nerve to say that humiliation before false religion is shameful, still know that Christ did not found His Church so that clerics could catechize the nations into anthropological sentimentality.

Peter “followed afar off”

That phrase deserves to be feared.

Peter does not immediately defect. He follows. But he follows at a distance. He wants sight of Christ without open association with Christ. He wants proximity without exposure. Soon enough he is warming himself in the enemy’s courtyard, and before long his mouth is full of oaths and curses.

A great deal of so-called conservative Catholicism lives in that courtyard. It still likes being seen as Catholic. It still wants the drama, the symbols, the argument, the identity. Yet it follows afar off. It keeps enough distance to remain acceptable. So it speaks boldly when the cost is low and falls quiet when the regime changes hands. It can rage at a dead crisis. It cannot name a living one. It can denounce yesterday’s humiliations. It tiptoes around today’s.

But Peter’s story in the Passion is not merely a warning, but also a consolation. He falls hard. He falls publicly. Then the cock crows. Then memory pierces him like a knife. Then comes bitter weeping. Christ had seen the denial before it happened and loved Peter anyway.

That is hope for souls who feel they have compromised, delayed, softened, excused too much. The answer to cowardice is not self-pity. It is bitter repentance. Better tears in the night than clever justifications in the courtyard. Better to go out and weep than to stay by the fire congratulating oneself on prudence.

“I looked for comforters, and I found none”

The Offertory may be the cry of many faithful Catholics now. We looked for comforters and found none. We looked for fathers and got managers. We looked for defenders and got brand consultants. We looked for clear denunciation of sacrilege, doctrinal corruption, and false worship and got process language, pastoral framing, and strategic ambiguity.

Very well. Then let Palm Sunday teach us where comfort actually lies.

Not in the hierarchy as such. Not in the media class. Not in the temporary moods of Rome. Comfort lies in the Passion itself, because the Passion reveals what the Church often looks like from the inside during her ugliest hours. Holiness appears defeated. Authority is weaponized against truth. The loyal are scattered. Public religion collaborates with injustice. The crowd is manipulated. The innocent are mocked. And God seems to be doing nothing.

Seems.

The Church has always had to learn that word. Seems. Christ seems abandoned. Christ seems powerless. Christ seems disproved. Christ seems buried. Yet at every step the liturgy whispers the opposite. “You have hold of my right hand.” “With Your counsel You guide me.” “In the end You will receive me in glory.” Psalm 21 begins in desolation and ends with a people yet unborn proclaiming the justice of God. The end is already hidden in the cry.

That is why faithful Catholics must refuse despair. Not optimism. Not naivety. Not the sugary insistence that everything is secretly fine. Despair is a deeper temptation than grief. Grief sees the wound. Despair declares the wound final. Palm Sunday forbids that conclusion.

Simon, Veronica, Magdalene, Joseph

The Passion is full of broken men, but it is also full of faithful presences who remain.

Simon of Cyrene carries what he did not choose.

The holy women stand where many men fled.

Joseph of Arimathea steps forward when the public cause looks lost.

The centurion recognizes what the theologians of the establishment refuse to confess.

That is the remnant. Not glamorous. Not usually in control. Sometimes frightened, sometimes late, sometimes pressed into service by circumstances they never would have chosen. Yet they are there when it counts.

Perhaps that is the calling of traditional Catholics in this hour. Simply to remain near the Passion of Christ without lying about what we see. To keep the Faith. To teach the children. To reject false worship. To honor the Holy Name. To refuse the narcotic of managed expectations. To carry the Cross assigned to us and not the one we would have designed for ourselves.

Palm Sunday is not sentimental. It does not promise a quick reversal. It promises something harder and better. If you endure with Christ, you will also rise with Him. If you stay awake in Gethsemani, you will understand Easter more deeply than those who slept through the agony. If you kneel where the Church tells you to kneel, before the true Lord Jesus Christ, no synodal bishop or pope, no committee, no idol, no jungle rite, no media blackout can rob you of the inheritance purchased by His Blood.

So enter Holy Week with open eyes.

Yes, the shepherds sleep.

Yes, some betray with a kiss.

Yes, Peter still follows afar off.

Yes, the priests of the age still know how to manufacture a case.

Yes, the crowd still prefers Barabbas.

But Christ still goes forward.

Christ still drinks the chalice.

Christ still reigns from the tree.

Christ still gathers His scattered own.

And after the stone, after the silence, after the burial, Christ still rises.

That is enough to keep a Catholic alive in any century.

---

If you value independent Catholic analysis and want to help keep this work going, you can make a contribution or subscribe below. Every donation and subscription directly supports the writing, research, and production of Hiraeth in Exile.

Thank you for helping preserve independent Catholic journalism rooted in truth and tradition.