Leo's Odd Synodal Theater (LOST) 3000

A Mystery Science Theater–style guide to Leo’s Nicaea speech

In case you’ve never wasted a perfectly good evening on Mystery Science Theater 3000, a quick primer. MST3K was a cult TV show where a poor guy trapped in space was forced to watch awful movies while he and a couple of robot sidekicks made snarky comments over the soundtrack. The plot was just an excuse for running commentary: the movie played straight, and the silhouettes in the front row dismantled it in real time. What follows is the same basic idea, except the “cheesy movie” is Leo’s address at the Phanar in Istanbul, the “robots” are gone, and it is just me in the front row. Leo’s words appear in quoted text; my commentary appears marked in boldface afterward. Think of it as Leo’s Odd Synodal Theater (LOST) 3000 : you get the official ecumenical script, and then you get what a halfway catechized Catholic would respond while watching it.

First play the LOST3K Intro Music on YouTube here:

Lyrics

In the not-too-distant present

Next Sunday A .D.

There is a man named Leo

Lost in aggiornamento seas

He is Rome’s new ecumenical recruit

Just another modernist in a white pope suit

He was riding on a donkey in Peru, his home

But when Francis kicked the bucket

Then they shot him off to Rome

They’ll send him cheesy homilies

The worst they can find (la-la-la)

He’ll have to preach and read them all

To pacify mankind (la-la-la)

Now keep in mind Leo can’t control

Where the buzzwords begin or end

So he drowns the faith in “listening”

And calls everyone his friend

Sin-odd roll call:

Tucho!

James Martin!

Ghost of Francis!

Roche!

If you’re wondering where your Masses went

And other Catholic facts (la-la-la)

Then repeat to yourself “It’s all a show

I should really just relax

for Leo’s Odd Synodal Theater 3000!

ADDRESS OF THE HOLY FATHER
AT THE CONCLUSION OF THE DIVINE LITURGY

Patriarchal Church of Saint George (Istanbul)
Sunday, 30 November 2025

[Multimedia]

____________________________________

Your All Holiness, beloved brother in Christ,
Your Beatitudes,
Dear brothers in the Episcopate,
Members of the Holy Synod of the Ecumenical Patriarchate,
Dear brothers and sisters!

Our pilgrimage to the places where the First Ecumenical Council in the history of the Church was held draws to a close with this solemn Divine Liturgy, in which we have commemorated the Apostle Andrew.

The Fathers came to Nicaea to smash a heresy and define dogma. We come back to Nicaea to film a vibes-based trailer for interreligious cooperation.

According to ancient tradition, he brought the Gospel to this city. His faith is the same as our faith, namely that which was defined by the Ecumenical Councils and is professed by the Church today.

Andrew’s faith is “the same” as ours, provided you ignore the part where he believed in one Church, one Faith, and one visible authority, not a synodal Costco of “legitimate differences” with complimentary coffee.

During this ecumenical prayer, together with the Heads of Churches and Representatives of Christian World Communities, we have recalled that the faith professed in the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed unites us in real communion and allows us to recognize each other as brothers and sisters.

“Real communion” now means we all recite almost the same Creed, modified where it might offend anyone who still remembers what it actually says.

In the past, there have been many misunderstandings and even conflicts between Christians of different Churches, and there are still obstacles preventing us from achieving full communion.

Ah yes, those little “misunderstandings”: papal primacy, the Filioque, rejection of Western councils, mutual excommunications. Just a few minor flubs in wording, nothing doctrinal, do move along.

Nevertheless, we must not relent in striving towards unity. We must continue to consider each other as brothers and sisters in Christ and to love one another accordingly.

Unity without conversion is just a very polite ceasefire. Everyone is “brother and sister,” nobody is ever told to repent and join the one Church they keep invoking.

Inspired by this awareness, sixty years ago Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras solemnly declared that the unfortunate decisions and sad events that led to the mutual excommunications of 1054 should be removed from the Church’s memory.

The new ecumenical method: if history is inconvenient, do a solemn ceremony to forget it ever happened. “Remove from the Church’s memory” is how you talk about a bad haircut, not a thousand-year schism. Also, can we remove Vatican II from the Church’s memory? There is apparently precedent.

That historic gesture by our venerable predecessors inaugurated a path of reconciliation, peace and growing communion between Catholics and Orthodox, which has been fostered through frequent contact, fraternal meetings and promising theological dialogue.

Frequent contact, fraternal meetings, promising dialogue. Everything but the one thing Nicaea would recognize: submission to the truth. You can almost hear St. Athanasius asking where in this “path” someone actually has to believe anything.

In light of the advances already made, significant steps have been taken at ecclesiological and canonical levels, and today we are called even more to commit ourselves to the restoration of full communion.

Whenever modern Rome says “advances at ecclesiological and canonical levels,” it usually means they changed the vocabulary and the footnotes, not the fact that one side still denies what the other side calls dogma.

In this regard, I wish to express my deep gratitude to His All Holiness and the Ecumenical Patriarchate for their ongoing support for the Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue between the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church.

The apostles built the Church by preaching, suffering, and shedding blood. We build “growing communion” by commissions, working documents, and photo-ops with pre-written talking points.

I also hope that every effort will be made to ensure that all the autocephalous Orthodox Churches return to take an active part in this endeavor.

Some of the Orthodox are not even bothering to show up for the synodal talk show, and yet we keep calling this “real communion.” When even the schismatics are bored, maybe the endeavor needs more than “every effort.”

For my part, in continuity with the teaching of the Second Vatican Council and my predecessors, I wish to confirm that, while respecting legitimate differences, the pursuit of full communion among all those baptized in the name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, is one of the priorities of the Catholic Church.

“In continuity with the teaching of the Second Vatican Council” is the polite way of saying: everything before 1962 will now be interpreted through an ecumenical blender. And “all those baptized” quietly replaces the old, unfashionable notion that membership in the Church actually requires the Catholic faith.

“Legitimate differences” has turned into a suitcase big enough to pack in papal primacy, the Filioque, the Immaculate Conception, Purgatory, and practically anything else that used to separate Catholics from non-Catholics. Whatever you do, never call a dogma by its name.

In particular, it is one of the priorities of my ministry as Bishop of Rome, whose specific role in the universal Church is to be at the service of all, building and safeguarding communion and unity.

Vatican I defined the pope as supreme pastor and teacher of all Christians with full and supreme power to guard the deposit of faith. Here the “Bishop of Rome” has been demoted to global HR manager of “communion and unity,” with doctrine as an optional sidebar.

In order to remain faithful to the Lord’s desire for us to care not only for our brothers and sisters in faith, but also for all of humanity and the whole of creation…

From “preach the Gospel to every creature” to “care for all of humanity and the whole of creation.” The Great Commission has been reissued as the Great Corporate Social Responsibility Statement.

…our Churches must respond together to the promptings of the Holy Spirit today. First of all, at this time of bloodstained conflict and violence in places both near and far, Catholics and Orthodox are called to be peacemakers.

We still will not say “submit to the truth,” but we will absolutely say “release a joint statement on peace.” It is the first beatitude rewritten: blessed are the press offices, for they shall be called peacemakers.

This certainly means taking action, making choices and adopting gestures that build peace…

“Adopting gestures that build peace” sounds less like apostolic preaching and more like a choreographed liturgy of handshakes and photo opportunities. The martyrs died; we adopt gestures.

while also acknowledging that peace is not merely the fruit of human effort, but is a gift from God.

Peace is a gift from God, yes, normally attached to conversion, repentance, and the true faith. All three have been quietly replaced here with the sacraments of Dialogue, Ecology, and New Technologies.

Peace, therefore, must be sought through prayer, penance, contemplation and nurturing a living relationship with the Lord, who helps us to discern what words, gestures and actions to undertake so that we can genuinely be at the service of peace.

Prayer, penance, contemplation; all excellent, all carefully disconnected from the one concrete demand the Fathers of Nicaea would make of Constantinople: renounce your errors and return to the Roman See. “Words, gestures and actions” is safe precisely because it never has to name the dogma.

A further challenge facing our Churches is the threatening ecological crisis, which His All Holiness has often said requires of us a spiritual, personal and communal conversion for changing direction and safeguarding creation.

At last we arrive at “conversion,” the one word conspicuously absent when talking about heresy and schism. The only real mission now is to convert your thermostat and your garbage sorting. Orthodox and Catholic? Optional. Recycling? Urgent.

Catholics and Orthodox alike are called to work together in promoting a new mindset so that everyone acknowledges responsibility for caring for the creation that God has entrusted to us.

The only “new mindset” anyone is allowed to question here is your attitude toward plastic straws and carbon emissions. The mindset that says there is one true Church outside of which there is no salvation is what actually has to be retired.

The third challenge that I would like to mention is the use of new technologies, especially in the field of communications.

Nicaea fought Arianism; our great historic moment at Nicaea is now about Wi-Fi, smartphones, and content moderation. The downgrade from heresiarchs to hashtags is complete.

Aware of the enormous advantages that they can offer humanity, Catholics and Orthodox must cooperate in promoting their responsible use. Indeed, these technologies must be placed at the service of integral human development, and be universally accessible, so as to ensure that their benefits are not reserved to a small number of people or the interests of a privileged few.

The path to “full communion” now apparently runs through equitable data plans and digital inclusion. We are one encyclical away from “Ut Unum Sint et Have Unlimited 5G.”

In addressing these challenges, I am confident that all Christians, the members of other religious traditions, and all men and women of good will can cooperate harmoniously in working together for the common good.

It starts with Nicaea and ends with the United Nations. The Catholic Church becomes just one NGO among many in the great faith of “men and women of good will working together for the common good.” The Creed has been quietly replaced by the mission statement.

Your All Holiness, with these heartfelt thoughts, I offer you and your brothers and sisters my most fervent wishes for good health and serenity as you celebrate the Feast of your patron saint. I would like to express my sincere gratitude for the warm and fraternal welcome you have extended to me during these days.

Health, serenity, warm and fraternal welcome. No mention of unity of faith, conversion, or obedience to the Roman Pontiff; just the ecumenical equivalent of a Hallmark card.

I entrust all of you, therefore, to the intercession of the Apostle Andrew and his brother Saint Peter, Saint George the Great Martyr to whom this Church is dedicated, the Holy Fathers of the First Council of Nicaea and the many Holy Pastors of this ancient and glorious Church of Constantinople. And I ask God, the Father of mercies, abundantly to bless all those present.

Hrònia Pollà! Ad multos annos!

Invoke Andrew, Peter, George, and the Fathers of Nicaea as mascots, then proceed as if none of them would have said a word about conversion, error, or the one true Church. The saints are asked to bless an arrangement they would almost certainly have died rather than endorse.

Let me off the ship, Dr. Forrester! I’ve seen enough!

If you value independent Catholic analysis and want to help keep this work going, you can make a contribution or subscribe below. Every donation and subscription directly supports the writing, research, and production of Hiraeth in Exile.

Thank you for helping preserve independent Catholic journalism rooted in truth and tradition.